The long awaited prequel trilogy to The Lord of the Rings will see the first of its’ three movies released tomorrow. Here is why I will not be seeing it.
For a long time I loved the movie adaptations by Peter Jackson of JRR Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings books. But then when I began to write a book of my own something strange happened. I could no longer stomach those movies. Why? Because they entirely missed the point and substituted one of its’ own.
The entire point of Tolkien’s masterpiece was to show that the Hobbits could fend off someone as dangerous as the wizard Saruman on their own. The Scouring of the Shire was the integral piece in this effort. Frodo and Sam experienced the One Ring(yes Sam too!) and were able to survive its’ poison. Merry and Pippin joined the armies of Rohan and Gonder, respectively, and were able to contribute big things(like the defeat of the Witch King of Angmar by Merry and the saving of Faramir by Pippin) despite their stature and status in the world.
When Gandalf departs from the four of them before they finally make it back home, he tells them that this(Saruman in the shire) is what they have been training for the entire time. So the fact that the biggest piece to Tolkien’s work was removed for the movies is an absolute travesty to any author who wonders if their own work will one day be treated in a similar fashion one day.
So with this in mind I closely followed the developments of The Hobbit production in the hopes that they (Jackson and company) would not make the same mistake twice. It is a profit making mistake to be sure, but it is still a mistake to ignore the original author’s intent. And so what have I learned? Bilbo will get a fair share of the focus, as is right. But Thorin will get the Aragorn treatment. Apparently you cannot have a movie where the Hobbits are the sole focus. Bilbo, if you read the book, actually leads the dwarves through most of the dangers they find on their way to the Lonely Mountain. But in the movie, Thorin, who does NOT look at all like a dwarf(see the picture at the bottom), will be the focus as leader and future king of Lonely Mountain.
So unless my family comes back from seeing it and says, “Bilbo was 95% of the focus”, I will not see the Hobbit.
Does this look like a dwarf to you??